Ben's Brain

Alma 39–42 — The Great Plan of Happiness

Properties2
tagsscripture-study, book-of-mormon, alma, come-follow-me/2024, jesus-christ, repentance, resurrection, justice, mercy, parenting
aliasesAlma 39-42, The Great Plan of Happiness, Alma’s Counsel to Corianton, Corianton and the Plan of Redemption

44 min read

Download this page as a PDF

Come, Follow Me — August 5–11, 2024

Official lesson: “The Great Plan of Happiness.” — Alma 39–42. The manual reads these chapters as one father’s response to a loved one’s serious mistake: Alma condemns sin without abandoning Corianton, teaches what happens after death, models faithful inquiry, and shows how Jesus Christ makes redemption possible without destroying justice.1

← Previous: Alma 36–38 — Look to God and Live | Next: Alma 43–52 — Stand Fast in the Faith of Christ →

Alma 39–42 — “The Great Plan of Happiness”

Key Verse

“And now, the plan of mercy could not be brought about except an atonement should be made; therefore God himself atoneth for the sins of the world.” — Alma 42:15

Why These Four Chapters Belong Together

Alma does not answer Corianton’s behavior with four chapters of shame. He tells the truth about the harm, gives his son concrete steps toward repair, and then spends most of the conversation teaching why return is possible.

The four chapters form one rescue:

  1. Alma 39 — Face the breach. Corianton forsook his ministry, followed Isabel, damaged trust among the Zoramites, and now must forsake sin, seek wise counsel, turn to the Lord, acknowledge his wrong, and return.
  2. Alma 40 — See the promised body. Christ will rise; every person will rise; spirit and body will be reunited in a “proper and perfect frame.” Corianton’s failure is serious, but failure is not his final form.
  3. Alma 41 — Learn what restoration means. Resurrection restores body to spirit; judgment also reveals and restores works and desires. God does not alchemize wickedness into happiness, but repentance can change what a person desires and sends into the world.
  4. Alma 42 — Let justice and mercy tell one story. Eden gives mortals space to repent. Law makes moral agency meaningful. Christ’s Atonement answers the demands of justice and allows mercy to claim the penitent. The conclusion is not “you are finished,” but “go thy way, declare the word.”

Adam Miller recommends reading the unit as a single father-son conversation rather than performing “drive-by scripture study” on isolated lines. In that whole-conversation reading, resurrection becomes the model for restoration: God’s work is to bring the corrupted into incorruption and the estranged back into His presence.2

The week’s governing truth is this: Jesus Christ does not make sin harmless; He makes repentance, repair, resurrection, and a genuinely new future possible.

What to Watch for While Reading

  • Mark every occurrence of my son. Alma’s correction remains inside a relationship.
  • Compare what Alma emphasizes about Corianton’s sin: not only private appetite, but forsaken ministry, injured trust, and hearts led away.
  • List the verbs of repentance in 39:9–13: repent, forsake, cross yourself, counsel, give heed, refrain, turn, return, acknowledge.
  • Notice how quickly Alma moves from “crimes” to “the coming of Christ” and “glad tidings.”
  • Mark the opening concern in each doctrinal chapter: Corianton’s mind is worried about resurrection (40:1), restoration (41:1), and justice (42:1).
  • Separate what Alma says he knows by revelation from what he calls his opinion or says “mattereth not.”
  • In Alma 40, distinguish a state or condition of soul from a complete geographical map of the spirit world.
  • Follow the word restored from body and spirit (40:23) to works and desires (41:3–6) to God’s presence (42:23).
  • Read “wickedness never was happiness” in its argument: wickedness cannot be restored as happiness because it is contrary to happiness’s nature.
  • Circle every name for God’s plan: happiness, redemption, salvation, restoration, mercy.
  • Trace the Eden sequence in Alma 42: Fall → separation → probationary time → law → repentance → Atonement → resurrection → judgment.
  • Hold justice, mercy, and long-suffering together. Alma says all three should have “full sway” in Corianton’s heart.
  • Watch the final commission. Repentance does not merely return Corianton to private respectability; it returns him to truthful ministry.

Historical and Literary Context

A Private Conversation in a Public Crisis

Alma has returned from the Zoramite mission. The Zoramites have expelled believers, joined the Lamanites, and helped create the conditions for war. Before the narrative turns to armies in Alma 43, Mormon pauses over Alma’s private charges to Helaman, Shiblon, and Corianton. See Alma Timeline Map and the preceding guide, Alma 36–38 — Look to God and Live.

Corianton’s failure is therefore both personal and public. He “forsook the ministry” and went after Isabel; when the Zoramites saw his conduct, “they would not believe” Alma’s words. The official manual identifies the conduct as sexual sin and uses the chapter to teach chastity, forgiveness, and healing.1 The text’s own emphasis also includes misuse of a sacred trust and harm to other people’s willingness to hear truth.

That larger frame matters pastorally. Alma does not reduce a person to one sexual failure, but neither does he pretend a private choice has no relational consequences. He speaks clearly enough to make accountability possible and hopefully enough to make return believable.

The Ending Is Part of the Interpretation

The manual points to Alma 49:30, where Corianton is again among those entrusted to preach. Alma’s counsel is not a transcript of a hopeless condemnation. It is part of a successful reclamation.

We do not know every step or elapsed interval in Corianton’s repentance. The text does show that Alma ends by calling him to preach, and Mormon later includes him among the faithful ministry. A wise reader therefore refuses to freeze Corianton forever in Alma 39:3. Scripture remembers the wrong truthfully and also remembers the returned disciple.

“Worried” Is the Refrain

Each of the last three chapters begins with Alma perceiving something that troubles Corianton’s mind:

ChapterCorianton’s worryAlma’s response
Alma 40resurrection of the deadChrist makes resurrection possible; the dead await resurrection; body and spirit will be restored
Alma 41restorationrestoration does not turn wickedness into happiness; it includes works, desires, mercy, and moral truth
Alma 42justice in punishmentEden gives space to repent; Christ satisfies justice and opens the plan of mercy

Jared Halverson emphasizes the parenting pattern: Alma tries to understand the beliefs and anxieties beneath the behavior. He does not only repeat “what you did was wrong”; he asks, in effect, What view of resurrection, judgment, and God has made either rationalization or despair seem reasonable to you?3

Alma Is Studying Abinadi

John Hilton III identifies at least thirteen textual relationships between Abinadi’s words in Mosiah 12–17 and Alma’s counsel in Alma 39–42. The parallels cluster around resurrection, the first resurrection, judgment, accountability, and redemption. This is literary scholarship rather than an official declaration about composition, but the pattern fits the family history: Alma the Elder heard and recorded Abinadi, and Alma the Younger now teaches the next generation in language shaped by that witness.4

The implication is spiritually rich. Abinadi’s sermon did not end at the stake. It entered Alma the Elder’s record, Alma the Younger’s vocabulary, Corianton’s reclamation, Mormon’s abridgment, and the reader’s present study. A word faithfully preserved can outlive the setting in which it first appeared.

Truth Without Abandonment: Alma 39

Alma Names the Wrong and Its Reach

Alma begins with contrast: Shiblon’s steadiness could have been a useful pattern, but Corianton “did not give so much heed.” The comparison is uncomfortable, and it should not be turned into a universal parenting formula. Its function in this personal letter is to make clear that Corianton knew a different way was possible.

Alma then names three linked failures:

  • misdirected desire: he boasted and went after Isabel;
  • abandoned covenant work: he forsook the ministry entrusted to him;
  • injured witness: Zoramites used his conduct as a reason not to believe Alma’s words.

Terry Ball reads the chapter as a model for teaching morality: tailor counsel to the actual learner, do not trivialize serious harm, explain accountability, make repentance concrete, direct the learner toward trustworthy counsel, and teach morality within Christ’s plan of redemption rather than as a detached code.5

This does not justify humiliating disclosure, obsessive interrogation, or treating a person as contaminated. Alma says why he dwells on the crime: “if it were not for thy good” (39:7). Correction that serves anger, control, or spectacle fails Alma’s stated test.

“Cross Yourself” Is Not Self-Hatred

“Go no more after the lusts of your eyes, but cross yourself in all these things.” — Alma 39:9

To “cross yourself” means refusing the rule of ungodly appetite. It does not mean despising the body or trying to atone through self-inflicted misery. Alma pairs it with specific, relational action:

  1. stop pursuing the sin;
  2. accept responsibility;
  3. seek nourishment and counsel from faithful brothers;
  4. turn to the Lord with mind, might, and strength;
  5. stop leading hearts away;
  6. return to those harmed;
  7. acknowledge the fault and wrong.

This belongs beside Repentance and the Atonement. Repentance is not an attempt to become one’s own savior. It is the honest turn that receives Christ’s saving and transforming power.

The Conversation Turns Toward Christ

Alma does not linger indefinitely over the crime. By verse 15 he announces that Christ “surely shall come to take away the sins of the world.” “Glad tidings” appears repeatedly at the chapter’s close.

Don’t Miss This calls attention to the proportion of the conversation: the wrong is faced, but most of Alma 39–42 is devoted to the rescue. Their practical reading of 39:9–13 defines repentance as turning toward the Lord, bringing hidden things into truthful light, receiving nourishing counsel, and acknowledging harm.6

The order matters:

  • Christ’s coming does not make acknowledgment unnecessary.
  • Acknowledgment does not make Christ’s coming unnecessary.
  • The gospel holds both: this mattered and the Savior is mighty to reclaim.

Faithful Inquiry: What Alma Knows and What He Does Not

Alma 40 is a rare scriptural window into a prophet thinking carefully and speaking with epistemic restraint.

Firm Center, Open Edges

Alma is certain that:

  • Christ will come and bring to pass the resurrection;
  • all people will rise at an appointed time known to God;
  • there is an interval between death and resurrection;
  • the dead continue as spirits;
  • resurrection reunites spirit and body;
  • the body will be restored in a proper and perfect frame;
  • resurrection returns people to stand before God and be judged.

Alma does not claim exhaustive knowledge about:

  • whether resurrection occurs at one, two, or three appointed times;
  • the precise relation of time as mortals measure it to God;
  • every detail in the order of the first resurrection;
  • whether a specific event occurs at Christ’s resurrection or afterward.

He says “it mattereth not,” “God knoweth,” “I do not say,” and “I give it as my opinion.” Ryan H. Sharp treats the passage as a case study in doctrinal development: start with what revelation establishes, distinguish central facts from secondary questions, continue inquiring, and leave future revelation room to clarify.7

This is not weak testimony. Alma knows enough to lead Corianton toward Christ while remaining honest about the boundaries of his knowledge.

Teaching Illustration — A Lit Path, Not a Floodlit Horizon

A path can be sufficiently lit for the next faithful steps without illuminating every mountain twenty miles away. Alma’s certainties illuminate Christ, resurrection, accountability, and return to God. His unanswered timing questions remain at the horizon. Faithfulness means walking in the light actually given—not pretending darkness is light and not refusing to walk until every horizon is floodlit.

Death, the Spirit World, and Resurrection

A State Before Resurrection

Alma says all spirits are “taken home to that God who gave them life.” He then contrasts a state of happiness, rest, and peace with a state of darkness, fear, and captivity. The word state is important. Alma is describing conditions of soul; this passage alone is not a complete architectural diagram of the spirit world.

Later revelation adds substantial light: Christ organized the righteous to carry the gospel to those in darkness, ordinances can be performed for the dead, and God judges people according to works and the desires of the heart (Doctrine and Covenants 137:7–9; 138:29–35, 57–59). We should let Restoration scripture clarify Alma without pretending Alma explicitly taught every later detail.

Resurrection Is Concrete Restoration

“The soul shall be restored to the body, and the body to the soul; yea, and every limb and joint shall be restored to its body.” — Alma 40:23

Resurrection is not merely the survival of an invisible self. Christ overcomes death so completely that embodied life is restored in incorruption. Paul similarly speaks of Christ as “the firstfruits” and of a body raised in incorruption and glory (1 Corinthians 15:20–23, 42–44).

Adam Miller uses this embodied promise as the controlling image for chapters 40–42: restoration is God’s insistence that corruption is not the final word. His interpretation—that resurrection provides the model for understanding restoration, justice, and corrective consequence—is devotional and philosophical, not an official definition of every punishment. It is valuable because it keeps Alma’s doctrine aimed toward Christ’s work of making whole.2

Teaching Illustration — The Restoration Workshop

Don’t Miss This compares restoration to refinishing furniture. Sanding reveals damage and removes what cannot remain, but the abrasive step is not the object of the project. The craftsperson is trying to recover integrity and beauty. Their devotional application is that Christ’s Atonement is not only a verdict at the project’s end; grace works throughout the restoring process.6

The illustration has limits: people are not objects, trauma is not always caused by sin, and God does not strip away personality to produce identical disciples. Its useful point is that exposure and correction serve wholeness; they are not the final product.

Restoration: Body, Works, Desires, and Truth

Not Merely the Latter-day Restoration

In Alma 40–41, restoration does not primarily mean the latter-day restoration of the Church. It means bringing again to a proper order:

DimensionWhat is restored
embodied lifespirit to body and body to spirit
incorruptionmortality and corruption to an immortal, proper frame
moral consequenceworks return as their true fruit
desirea heart’s actual orientation is disclosed and answered
relationshipevery person is brought again into God’s presence for judgment

The physical and moral meanings belong together. Resurrection guarantees return; judgment discloses what kind of life and communion a person has learned to desire.

Works Matter, and Desires Matter

Alma does not teach salvation by scorecard. He names both works and “the desires of their hearts.” A good desire is not a loophole for refusing action, because desire grows, speaks, chooses, repents, and bears fruit. Neither is failed performance proof that a person never desired good.

The sacrament prayer’s word willing is useful here. A disciple may be weak, inconsistent, and still genuinely willing to take Christ’s name and keep returning. God can educate desire and strengthen action rather than defining the person forever by the worst completed act.

Miller’s followHIM discussion makes this point sharply: judgment is not simply a tally of good and bad items; Alma gives decisive weight to what the heart has come to want. Miller further suggests—explicitly marking this as interpretation—that people often pursue a genuine good in a destructive way because they misunderstand where the good is found. Corianton may have wanted love or intimacy but pursued it in a way that harmed himself, Isabel, and the Zoramites. Redemption therefore includes an education of desire: learning what good actually is and how covenant love receives and gives it.2

“Wickedness Never Was Happiness”

“Behold, I say unto you, wickedness never was happiness.” — Alma 41:10

This line is often used as a warning that sin eventually makes people miserable. In context, it makes a more precise claim: restoration cannot place a thing into a state contrary to its nature. Wickedness cannot be restored as happiness because it never possessed the covenant wholeness, truthful love, and communion that happiness names.

That does not mean people in sin never feel pleasure, attachment, relief, excitement, or social approval. It means those experiences cannot turn exploitation, betrayal, or estrangement into eternal happiness. Nor does the verse authorize disciples to gloat while another person suffers. Alma’s next instruction is to send out mercy, justice, righteous judgment, and continual good.

“That Which Ye Do Send Out”

Alma’s harvest language is both warning and invitation:

“That which ye do send out shall return unto you again, and be restored.” — Alma 41:15

If Corianton wants mercy restored, he can begin sending mercy. If he wants trustworthy ministry restored, he can return and live truthfully. Grace is not earned by creating a favorable cosmic transaction; Christ makes return possible. Yet the life grace creates is participatory. The restored disciple joins God’s restoring work.

Eden, Justice, Mercy, and the Atonement

Why Alma Goes Back to the Garden

Corianton thinks it unjust that a sinner should be consigned to misery. Alma does not answer with a bare assertion that God may punish anyone He chooses. He retells the Fall.

In the Garden of Eden, partaking of the tree of knowledge brings temporal and spiritual separation. Guarding the tree of life prevents Adam and Eve from becoming immortal immediately in a fallen condition. The delay creates a space for repentance—a probationary or preparatory state in which people can hear, choose, change, and receive Christ.

Gift within mortalityWhy it matters
separation from Edenmakes agency and mortal experience real
timegives space to learn, repent, repair, and become
lawidentifies good and evil and makes accountability meaningful
consequencetells the truth about what choices produce
repentancepermits a real turn rather than permanent fixation in failure
Atonementallows mercy to reclaim without declaring evil good
resurrectionovercomes temporal death and returns all to God
judgmentreveals works, desires, and chosen relation to God

The Fall is not the rival of the plan of happiness. Within God’s redemptive design, mortality’s difficult space becomes the setting in which mercy can work.

Justice and Mercy Are Not Competing Personalities

Alma’s argument does not portray an angry Father whom a kinder Son persuades to stop being just. “God himself atoneth.” The same divine plan establishes law, grants repentance, sends the Son, brings resurrection, exercises justice, and extends mercy.

Daniel B. Sharp notes that Alma draws upon Nephite teaching about the Fall and redemption to answer Corianton’s specific misconception. The Atonement does not erase moral order; it makes a merciful return possible within that order.8

A careful synthesis is:

  • Justice refuses to call exploitation love, betrayal trust, or wickedness happiness.
  • Mercy refuses to declare the repentant person permanently identical with the wrong.
  • The Atonement of Jesus Christ bears and overcomes sin and death so that both truth and reclamation can stand.
  • Repentance is the God-granted condition of turning through which mercy claims a willing person.

The Check-Engine Light

In followHIM, John Bytheway compares corrective consequence to a check-engine light. The light is unwelcome, but disabling it does not heal the engine. Its purpose is to prevent greater damage and direct the driver toward repair.2

The metaphor should not be used to label every illness, loss, or hardship as punishment for sin. Many sufferings are not self-caused. Its proper use is narrower: when conscience, truthful feedback, or consequence exposes actual harm, mercy does not require us to smash the warning light. Mercy helps us stop, tell the truth, seek Christ, and repair what can be repaired.

“Only That Trouble Which Shall Bring You Down unto Repentance”

Alma does not glorify unlimited shame:

“I desire that ye should let these things trouble you no more, and only let your sins trouble you with that trouble which shall bring you down unto repentance.” — Alma 42:29

This gives sorrow a covenant test. Does it move toward:

  • honest acknowledgment?
  • forsaking and changed action?
  • confession and repair?
  • Christ’s mercy?
  • renewed service?

Or does it move toward hiding, paralysis, self-hatred, isolation, and the belief that no future exists? The latter may feel morally intense, but it does not perform the work Alma asks sorrow to do. Severe depression, trauma, or suicidal thought requires compassionate spiritual care and competent professional help; this passage must never be weaponized to tell a suffering person simply to feel less.

Full Sway

Alma tells Corianton not to deny justice or excuse sin, but also to let God’s justice, mercy, and long-suffering have “full sway” in his heart. Halverson imagines this as extending both arms for balance: refusing both the extreme of self-excusing and the extreme of hopeless self-condemnation.3

The decisive fact is that Christ has the perfect reach. He tells the whole truth, offers real mercy, and is long-suffering while disciples learn to walk in that truth.

Verse-by-Verse Commentary

Alma 39

Alma 39:1–4 — A Forsaken Ministry and Misdirected Heart

“Thou didst forsake the ministry, and did go over … after the harlot Isabel.”

Alma contrasts Corianton with Shiblon, names boasting, and identifies the breach of trust. Isabel “stole away the hearts of many,” but Alma refuses to let that fact become an excuse: “this was no excuse for thee.” Another person’s influence does not erase Corianton’s agency.

The text gives no account from Isabel’s perspective. Teachers should not turn her into a symbol for blaming women for men’s choices. Alma directs responsibility to his son: you forsook; you went; this was no excuse for you.

Come, Follow Me connection: when naming harmful influence, keep moral agency with the person whose repentance is being invited.

Alma 39:5–8 — Seriousness, Accountability, and “For Thy Good”

“I would not dwell upon your crimes, to harrow up thy soul, if it were not for thy good.”

Alma ranks Corianton’s conduct among grave sins and says hidden crimes cannot be hidden from God. The point is not that public exposure is always required or that forgiveness is impossible. The point is that secrecy cannot turn wrong into innocence.

Verse 7 governs the manner of correction: Alma raises the matter for Corianton’s good. Ball’s teaching analysis is helpful—do not minimize the wrong, but make the way of repentance equally clear.5

Come, Follow Me connection: before correcting someone, ask whether the content, timing, and manner genuinely serve that person’s good rather than the corrector’s need to vent.

Alma 39:9–13 — A Concrete Route of Return

“Turn to the Lord with all your mind, might, and strength.”

Alma’s commands form a practical repentance map: forsake lust, cross yourself, seek nourishing counsel, refrain from iniquity, turn to the Lord, stop leading others away, return, and acknowledge wrong. “Acknowledge your faults” includes relational truth; repentance is not only an inward feeling known to God.

Restitution must be wise. Acknowledgment should not disclose private sexual details to an audience that has no stewardship, expose another person, or create additional harm. The principle is to tell necessary truth to God, proper priesthood leaders where appropriate, and people directly harmed in a way guided by love and sound counsel.

Restoration parallel: Doctrine and Covenants 58:42–43 joins forgiveness with confession and forsaking.

Come, Follow Me connection: choose one verb from Alma’s map that turns repentance from an intention into today’s faithful act.

Alma 39:14–19 — Glad Tidings for a BC Disciple

“It is he that surely shall come to take away the sins of the world.”

Corianton wonders why Christ’s coming should be known so far in advance. Alma answers that souls are as precious before Christ’s mortal ministry as afterward, and angels can declare God’s word in either period.

The repeated “glad tidings” reframes the whole rebuke. Corianton’s calling was to announce salvation; Alma now gives that salvation back to him as the center of his own repentance.

Come, Follow Me connection: correction becomes Christian when it leads distinctly and quickly to the Christ who can take away sin.

Alma 40

Alma 40:1–5 — Diligent Inquiry and Honest Limits

“I show unto you one thing which I have inquired diligently of God that I might know.”

Alma answers Corianton’s worry by naming the fixed center: no resurrection precedes Christ’s resurrection; there is an appointed time; God knows it. Whether there are one, two, or three appointed times “mattereth not” to the saving point.

He models three sentences disciples need:

  • “This has been revealed.”
  • “This is my considered opinion.”
  • “God knows; I do not.”

Come, Follow Me connection: write one gospel question you will inquire about diligently and one secondary detail you can leave peacefully with God.

Alma 40:6–10 — Mortal Clocks Do Not Govern God

“All is as one day with God, and time only is measured unto men.”

Alma’s point is not to give a formula for converting divine time into earth years. It is to release the doctrine of resurrection from the assumption that God experiences appointment and sequence exactly as mortals do.

The death of people at different times implies an interval before resurrection. Alma asks what becomes of souls during that interval and reports what an angel made known.

Come, Follow Me connection: do not let an unanswered timing question eclipse the revealed promise that Christ will raise the dead.

Alma 40:11–14 — Home to God; Contrasting States

“The spirits of all men … are taken home to that God who gave them life.”

The righteous enter a state called paradise—happiness, rest, and peace. Those who choose evil enter darkness, fear, and captivity. These stark contrasts address Corianton’s moral urgency. Later revelation expands the picture of redemptive teaching among the dead without making Alma’s central contrast meaningless.

Ryan Sharp cautions against forcing Alma’s limited description to say everything Doctrine and Covenants 76, 137, and 138 later reveal. Alma’s transparency teaches that living revelation can add real understanding.7

Come, Follow Me connection: let the promise of being taken home shape grief, while leaving unrevealed geography and timetables unrevealed.

Alma 40:15–21 — “I Give It as My Opinion”

“Now, I do not say that their resurrection cometh at the resurrection of Christ; but behold, I give it as my opinion.”

Some had called the transition at death a “first resurrection,” but Alma defines resurrection more precisely as reunion of body and spirit. He then reasons about who rises at Christ’s resurrection and labels his inference as opinion.

Prophetic candor is a form of reverence. Alma does not place his own conclusion under God’s name merely to make the lesson feel complete.

Come, Follow Me connection: in teaching, distinguish scripture, official doctrine, informed interpretation, personal opinion, and open question.

Alma 40:22–26 — The Proper and Perfect Frame

“Every limb and joint shall be restored … even a hair of the head shall not be lost.”

Resurrection is universal and embodied. People are brought before God to be judged according to works. Alma’s binary account places happiness and misery in sharp contrast because Corianton needs to understand that choices are not morally weightless.

The promise of bodily restoration is especially tender in disability, age, injury, and death. It should not be used to demean mortal bodies or imply that disabled people have lives of lesser present worth.

Biblical parallel: John 5:28–29 and 1 Corinthians 15:42–44.

Come, Follow Me connection: Christ’s resurrection promises not escape from embodied personhood but its immortal redemption.

Alma 41

Alma 41:1–4 — “All Things” Restored

“The soul of man should be restored to its body, and that every part of the body should be restored to itself.”

Alma moves from physical restoration to moral order. Body returns to spirit; corruption becomes incorruption; works also return in their true character. The plan does not simply rewind life to Edenic innocence. It carries embodied persons into judgment and accountable relationship with God.

Abinadi and Amulek had already connected resurrection with restoration (Mosiah 15:19–26; Alma 11:42–45). Alma develops that inherited witness for Corianton’s need.

Come, Follow Me connection: ask what Christ promises to restore and what repentance asks you to stop carrying forward.

Alma 41:5–8 — Desires and “Their Own Judges”

“The one raised to happiness according to his desires of happiness.”

Works matter, but desire is not a footnote. A person who repents and desires righteousness can be “rewarded unto righteousness.” Those redeemed from darkness “stand or fall” and are “their own judges.”

This does not mean God is absent from judgment. It means judgment reveals rather than arbitrarily manufactures a person’s chosen relation to truth, goodness, and God. Doctrine and Covenants 137:9 later explicitly joins works and desires.

Come, Follow Me connection: instead of asking only “What did I complete?” ask “What am I learning to love, and what do my repeated choices teach my heart to want?”

Alma 41:9–11 — Do Not Risk One More Offense

“Wickedness never was happiness.”

Alma refuses procrastination. Corianton must not wrest scripture into a promise that resurrection will make unrepented wickedness happy. A “state of nature” without God is contrary to the nature of happiness—not because God jealously withholds joy, but because covenant joy is life with God.

“Never” reaches both directions: wickedness did not secretly become happiness while hidden, and resurrection will not relabel it later.

Come, Follow Me connection: identify one counterfeit good—control mistaken for peace, attention for love, secrecy for freedom, pleasure for wholeness—and name the real good being sought.

Alma 41:12–15 — Send Out Mercy

“See that ye are merciful unto your brethren; deal justly, judge righteously, and do good continually.”

Restoration cannot place a thing opposite to its nature. Alma therefore invites Corianton to begin participating in the future he desires: send mercy, justice, righteous judgment, and good into the world.

This is not a mechanical promise that every good deed receives an immediate equivalent reward. Corianton’s own father has suffered despite righteousness. It is a covenant claim that no faithful good is lost and that becoming merciful prepares the soul to receive mercy as gift.

Come, Follow Me connection: send out one form of the life you hope Christ restores in you—truth, fidelity, mercy, repair, or steady service.

Alma 42

Alma 42:1–5 — Eden and the Mercy of Time

“It was appointed unto man to die … there was a space granted unto man in which he might repent.”

Corianton supposes punishment is unjust. Alma starts with exile from Eden and the guarded tree of life. Immediate immortality in sin would frustrate the plan; mortality creates space before final restoration.

Miller calls this “the gift of the mercy of time.” The Fall’s hardship is real, but delay is not divine neglect. Time permits learning, repentance, covenant, repair, and transformation.2

Restoration parallel: 2 Nephi 2:15–27 and Moses 6:48–62.

Come, Follow Me connection: treat today not as proof God has postponed life, but as granted space in which a real turn can begin.

Alma 42:6–12 — Temporal and Spiritual Death

“Man became lost forever, yea, they became fallen man.”

The Fall brings temporal death—the separation of body and spirit—and spiritual death—separation from God’s presence. Left to itself, fallen life cannot reclaim itself. The phrase “lost forever” describes the trajectory without redemption, not the failure of Christ’s mission.

The plan of happiness must address both deaths. Resurrection answers temporal death universally. Christ also makes repentance and reconciliation possible so spiritual separation need not remain a person’s chosen state.

Come, Follow Me connection: do not reduce salvation either to a resurrected body without reconciled relationship or to inward spirituality without Christ’s victory over physical death.

Alma 42:13–15 — God Himself Atoneth

“Mercy could not take effect except it should destroy the work of justice. Now the work of justice could not be destroyed.”

If mercy merely announced that evil had become good, moral agency and trust would collapse. Instead, “God himself atoneth.” Christ enters the consequences of sin and death, satisfies the demands of justice, and brings about the plan of mercy.

Alma does not give a complete philosophical mechanics of Atonement. He gives Corianton the saving center: justice is real, mercy is real, and their unity is accomplished in Jesus Christ rather than in Corianton’s excuses or self-punishment.

Come, Follow Me connection: when caught between minimizing sin and believing sin is unforgivable, look to the God who neither lies about the wound nor refuses to heal it.

Alma 42:16–25 — Law, Punishment, Repentance, Mercy

“There is a law given, and a punishment affixed, and a repentance granted.”

Law makes transgression intelligible; consequence makes agency consequential; repentance is granted; mercy comes because of the Atonement and claims the penitent. Justice “exerciseth all his demands,” while mercy “claimeth all which is her own.”

The grammar prevents two distortions:

  • repentance is not self-rescue—it is a granted way to receive Christ;
  • mercy is not moral indifference—it claims people who turn rather than calling the wrong harmless.

Modern revelation: Doctrine and Covenants 19:4–12 warns against assuming that “eternal punishment” means punishment without redemptive purpose or divinely appointed end in every case.

Come, Follow Me connection: receive repentance as a gift to practice, not a sentence to postpone or a price meant to purchase God’s love.

Alma 42:26–28 — The Waters of Life Are Free, and Agency Remains

“Whosoever will come may come and partake of the waters of life freely.”

The invitation is universal, free, and unforced. God’s intent to save does not become coercion. A person may refuse to come; the refusal is restored according to deeds. The plan protects both the generosity of grace and the reality of agency.

This is why invitation matters. Manipulation can produce outward compliance while frustrating the very agency through which covenant love must be chosen.

Come, Follow Me connection: make Christ’s invitation unmistakably generous without trying to seize another person’s timetable or conscience.

Alma 42:29–31 — Productive Sorrow, Full Sway, and a Calling

“Let the justice of God, and his mercy, and his long-suffering have full sway in your heart.”

Alma’s final movement is astonishing. He tells Corianton to stop being troubled except by sorrow that produces repentance; stop excusing himself; receive justice, mercy, and patience together; become humble; then go preach truth and sobriety so others can repent.

The conclusion confirms the purpose of everything before it. Alma does not need Corianton to feel perpetually ruined. He needs him to become truthful, penitent, merciful, and useful in God’s work.

Come, Follow Me connection: repentance reaches maturity when received mercy becomes sober witness and repairing service.

Assigned Reading

  • Alma 39 — Corianton’s wrong, its effects, a concrete route of repentance, and glad tidings of Christ.
  • Alma 40 — diligent inquiry, the state between death and resurrection, and restoration of body and spirit.
  • Alma 41 — restoration of works and desires; wickedness never was happiness; send out mercy and good.
  • Alma 42 — Eden, probation, law, repentance, Atonement, justice, mercy, and Corianton’s renewed commission.

Key Book of Mormon Parallels

  • Mosiah 15:19–26 — Abinadi on Christ, resurrection, and the first resurrection.
  • Alma 11:40–45 — Amulek on resurrection, incorruption, and return to God for judgment.
  • Alma 12:21–37 — Alma’s earlier public teaching on Eden, probation, resurrection, and the plan of redemption.
  • 2 Nephi 2:15–27 — opposition, the Fall, joy, redemption, and freedom to choose.
  • Alma 49:30 — Corianton later restored to ministry.

Bible, Pearl of Great Price, and Doctrine and Covenants

Teaching Illustrations and Activities

1. One Conversation, Four Cards

Place four cards in order:

  1. Tell the truth — Alma 39
  2. Promise resurrection — Alma 40
  3. Teach restoration — Alma 41
  4. Unite justice and mercy in Christ — Alma 42

Remove any card and ask what distortion follows:

  • no truth → cheap comfort;
  • no resurrection → failure feels final;
  • no restoration of works/desires → agency feels weightless;
  • no Atonement → justice becomes despair.

Then return every card and place Jesus Christ across the whole sequence.

2. The Check-Engine Light

Show a warning-light icon. Ask:

  • Why is the light unpleasant?
  • Why would covering it with tape be less merciful than reading it?
  • What is the difference between a warning and a verdict that the car is worthless?
  • Which response resembles repentance: smashing the light, staring at it forever, or seeking repair?

Add the pastoral limit: not every hardship is a warning about personal sin.

3. Furniture Restoration

Use photographs of one piece of furniture before, during, and after restoration. Label the stages:

  • truthful assessment;
  • removal of what is damaging;
  • repair and strengthening;
  • patient refinishing;
  • returned use.

Ask where grace operates. The answer is through the whole process, not only in the final photograph.

4. Certainty and Opinion Columns

Read Alma 40:1–21 and sort statements into:

  • revealed certainty;
  • Alma’s reasoned opinion;
  • detail that “mattereth not” to the central truth;
  • question still open to further revelation.

Discuss why honest labels can strengthen rather than weaken testimony.

5. Desire, Method, Fruit

Draw three columns:

DesireMethod chosenFruit
lovemanipulationmistrust
peaceavoidanceunresolved harm
belongingbetrayal of covenantisolation
truthhumble inquirygrowing light
mercyrepentance and mercy toward othersrepaired relationship

Invite learners to distinguish a good desire from a counterfeit way of pursuing it. Emphasize that this is an interpretive exercise, not permission to excuse harmful methods.

6. “Send Out” Experiment

Place four items or words in a basket: mercy, justice, righteous judgment, continual good. Each learner chooses one and names a concrete way to send it into a relationship this week. At the next discussion, ask what changed in the giver—not whether an equivalent reward arrived immediately.

7. Full Sway

Hold one object labeled justice in one hand and another labeled mercy and long-suffering in the other. Notice what happens when either arm is held close while the other extends fully. Then extend both.

Ask:

  • What does justice say truthfully about harm?
  • What does mercy say truthfully about Christ and a repentant future?
  • Why does long-suffering belong with both?

8. Productive and Destructive Sorrow

Create two paths from the word sorrow:

  • truth → turning → confession → repair → Christ → renewed service;
  • hiding → isolation → self-hatred → paralysis → hopelessness.

Alma gives sorrow a destination: “that trouble which shall bring you down unto repentance.” Discuss where a person may need pastoral, family, medical, or mental-health support to leave the destructive path.

9. Read the Ending First

Read Alma 49:30 before beginning Alma 39. Ask how knowledge of Corianton’s later ministry changes the way learners hear Alma’s correction. It does not erase the wrong; it prevents the reader from treating the wrong as Corianton’s permanent name.

Questions for Personal Study or Teaching

  1. Why does Mormon preserve Corianton’s private correction before the war narrative?
  2. What harms does Alma name beyond the sexual act itself?
  3. How can a teacher condemn a sin without reducing a person to that sin?
  4. What does “for thy good” require of the person giving correction?
  5. Which repentance verb in Alma 39:9–13 is easiest to postpone?
  6. What is the difference between exposing truth and humiliating a person?
  7. Why does Alma tell Corianton to seek nourishment from his brothers?
  8. How can trusted counsel preserve rather than displace personal agency?
  9. Why does Alma move to Christ’s coming by verse 15?
  10. What would make “glad tidings” credible to someone who has caused real harm?
  11. What had Alma inquired diligently to know?
  12. Which statements in Alma 40 does Alma hold firmly, and which does he label as opinion?
  13. Why is “God knoweth” sometimes a faithful stopping point rather than an intellectual failure?
  14. What does state communicate that a detailed spirit-world map might obscure?
  15. How does Doctrine and Covenants 138 add light without requiring us to pretend Alma already stated it all?
  16. Why is bodily resurrection the starting model for restoration?
  17. What does “proper and perfect frame” promise without demeaning mortal limitation?
  18. How do works and desires belong together at judgment?
  19. Which genuinely good desire have you sometimes pursued by a harmful or ineffective method?
  20. Why can wickedness provide pleasure without ever becoming covenant happiness?
  21. What are you “sending out” repeatedly into your closest relationships?
  22. Why does Alma use Eden to answer a question about justice?
  23. How can mortal delay be “space for repentance” rather than evidence of abandonment?
  24. What would collapse if mercy simply renamed wickedness as goodness?
  25. What would collapse if justice allowed no repentant future?
  26. What does “God himself atoneth” teach about God’s character?
  27. Why is repentance described as something “granted”?
  28. How can consequence function like a warning light without every hardship being labeled punishment?
  29. What kind of trouble leads you toward repentance? What kind drives you into hiding?
  30. What changes when justice, mercy, and long-suffering all have full sway?
  31. Why does Alma end with a ministry commission rather than a probationary silence?
  32. What does Alma 49:30 teach about how scripture remembers a repentant person?

Personal Covenant Application

Tell One Necessary Truth

Name one wrong, rationalization, or pattern without euphemism. Tell God the truth. Determine whether a trusted leader, counselor, or harmed person also needs an honest acknowledgment. Seek wise guidance so disclosure serves repair rather than creating new harm.

Choose One Turn

From Alma 39:9–13, choose one verb for the week:

  • forsake;
  • cross yourself;
  • counsel;
  • give heed;
  • refrain;
  • turn;
  • return;
  • acknowledge.

Attach it to a time, person, and action.

Make an Inquiry Ledger

Divide a page into three columns:

  1. what scripture and authorized teaching establish;
  2. my current interpretation or opinion;
  3. what I still do not know.

Pray and study diligently without disguising column two as column one.

Practice the Mercy of Time

Treat one day as granted space rather than a delayed verdict. Use it for one repair, one prayer, one act of embodied care, and one step back toward useful service.

Educate a Desire

Name something good you want—love, peace, intimacy, belonging, justice, relief, or recognition. Ask:

  • Is my current method consistent with the good itself?
  • Whom does it bless or injure?
  • What covenant method would let Christ educate this desire?

Let the Warning Serve Repair

When truthful discomfort appears, do not immediately numb it or turn it into self-contempt. Ask what good response is now needed. If the issue exceeds your capacity, seek qualified help; receiving help can itself be repentance’s honest turn.

Send Out Mercy Without Avoiding Justice

Do one merciful act that does not lie about harm: forgive a debt of irritation, listen before judging, set a protective boundary without contempt, make restitution, or offer a repentant person a non-naive path back to trust.

Return to Ministry

Identify useful service that shame has tempted you to abandon. Do not assume every former role must be resumed immediately or without authorized clearance. Ask what truthful, safe, humble service is available now. Corianton’s model is not instant image restoration; it is eventual faithful participation.

Pulling It Together

Alma’s conversation with Corianton begins where many painful family conversations begin: a loved one has done something serious, harmed other people, and compromised trust. Alma refuses two false mercies. He will not call the wrong harmless, and he will not call his son hopeless.

Chapter 39 opens the wound in order to clean it. Corianton must stop, forsake, seek counsel, turn to the Lord, return to people harmed, and acknowledge his wrong. Yet Alma moves quickly to “glad tidings”: Jesus Christ will come to take away the sins of the world.

Chapter 40 opens the future. Christ’s Resurrection guarantees that corruption and death do not define the final body. Alma also shows how a prophet seeks: inquire diligently, say what revelation establishes, identify opinion, and leave lesser timing questions with God.

Chapter 41 expands restoration from body to moral life. Works matter. Desires matter. Wickedness cannot be relabeled happiness, but the repentant can desire righteousness, send out mercy, and become capable of receiving the life Christ offers.

Chapter 42 returns to Eden. Mortality is difficult granted space. Law tells the truth about agency; consequence tells the truth about fruit; repentance is granted; God Himself atones; resurrection returns every person to His presence; mercy claims the penitent without destroying justice.

Alma’s last word to Corianton is therefore not hide. It is not excuse. It is not punish yourself forever. It is: let justice, mercy, and long-suffering have full sway; become humble; go; declare truth; help other people repent.

The great plan of happiness is great enough to tell the whole truth about sin and still end with a resurrected body, a reclaimed heart, and a renewed calling in Jesus Christ.

← Previous: Alma 36–38 — Look to God and Live | Next: Alma 43–52 — Stand Fast in the Faith of Christ →

Annotated Source Guide

  • Official Come, Follow Me manual: establishes the exact lesson title, date, reading, and official emphases: avoiding sexual sin, forgiveness and healing through Christ, the postmortal spirit world and resurrection, faithful inquiry, and the Atonement’s reconciliation of justice and mercy.1
  • BYU Studies lesson 32 index: audited first and retained locally. It supplies the chapter-by-chapter map to Terry Ball on moral teaching, John Hilton on Abinadi intertext, Richard Cowan on restoration, scholarship on the spirit world and Alma’s use of state, and resources on resurrection and Atonement.9
  • Adam Miller / followHIM (2024): the strongest current-year local source for reading the four chapters as one conversation, resurrection as the model of restoration, God’s intent to bring people home, desires at judgment, corrective consequence as pedagogy, mortality as the mercy of time, and present participation in restoration. These are identified as Miller’s philosophical/devotional interpretations where they go beyond the text.2
  • Jared Halverson / Unshaken: strongest for Alma’s movement from behavior to the beliefs beneath it, “for thy good,” concrete repentance, horizontal counsel from brothers, Christ-centered hope, the three “worried” openings, and the full-sway balance of justice, mercy, and long-suffering.3
  • David Butler and Emily Belle Freeman / Don’t Miss This: strongest for repentance as turning toward God, honest acknowledgment, Alma’s open inquiry, furniture restoration as a process, works joined with desires, and Eden as the focused scriptural story Alma uses to teach Corianton.6
  • Terry B. Ball: gives a structured pedagogical reading of Alma 39. His article helps preserve both moral seriousness and a visible route of repentance. Some dated cultural examples in the article are not necessary to accept his textual teaching pattern.5
  • John Hilton III: identifies a substantial cluster of textual relationships between Abinadi and Alma 39–42. This guide treats the pattern as literary scholarship and uses it to illuminate scriptural transmission, not as a required doctrinal conclusion.4
  • Ryan H. Sharp: helps distinguish Alma’s firm resurrection witness from his acknowledged opinions and later Restoration clarification. The chapter supports faithful inquiry without anachronistically putting Doctrine and Covenants 76, 137, or 138 in Alma’s mouth.7
  • Daniel B. Sharp: provides a focused scholarly account of Alma’s use of Fall, law, justice, mercy, and Atonement to answer Corianton. Scholarly analysis, not a substitute for the scriptural text.8

Source Availability Audit

The official manual page and BYU Studies lesson 32 index were reviewed for this exact week. The matching 2024 followHIM proofread PDF was already present in two identical local locations; the canonical Sources/PDFs/ copy was verified as a nontrivial PDF and extracted during this run to a searchable Markdown companion. Matching local Unshaken and Don’t Miss This transcripts were found and used with bounded reads. The local Gospel Talktrine Book of Mormon collection currently has no matching Alma 39–42 episode in its preserved sequence; it skips from S03E26 to later episodes. No matching local Scripture Central transcript was found, though the BYU Studies index links John Hilton’s relevant Scripture Central video and other canonical resources. These statements report this run’s local audit, not permanent unavailability.

Footnotes

Footnotes

  1. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, “August 5–11: ‘The Great Plan of Happiness.’ Alma 39–42,” Come, Follow Me—For Home and Church: Book of Mormon 2024 (2023), https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/manual/come-follow-me-for-home-and-church-book-of-mormon-2024/32?lang=eng. Official Church curriculum. The lesson page explicitly treats Corianton’s conduct as sexual sin; asks readers to examine its causes, consequences, repentance, and Christ’s healing; asks what happens after death; highlights Alma’s faithful inquiry; and organizes Alma 42 around God’s justice, mercy, and the Savior’s Atonement. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  2. Adam S. Miller with Hank Smith and John Bytheway, “Alma 39–42 — ‘The Great Plan of Happiness,’” followHIM: A Come, Follow Me Podcast, BM-32 (2024), proofread PDF BM-32 followHIM PDF, searchable extraction BM-32 followHIM transcript. See extraction lines 293–403 (one conversation, Alma’s candor, chapter sequence, and resurrection as restoration’s model), 429–466 (God’s plan brings home rather than blocks), 561–659 (proper frame and reproving followed by increased love), 774–916 (justice, pedagogical consequence, check-engine light, and productive repentance), 998–1049 (Eden and the mercy of time), 1130–1254 (judgment, works, and desires), 1511–1585 (“wickedness never was happiness”), and 1692–1858 (present-tense restoration and Atonement). Devotional/philosophical expert interview, not official Church teaching. Miller’s claims about punishment, natural goodness, and the education of desire are presented as his interpretive reading. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6

  3. Jared Halverson, “Come Follow Me — Alma 39–42 — Redeeming the Prodigal Son,” Unshaken (Faith Matters), local generated transcript Come Follow Me — Alma 39–42 — Redeeming the Prodigal Son, original video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gL2FoYy05EE. See transcript lines 139–153 (belief beneath behavior and the chapter sequence), 300–336 (public witness, “for thy good,” and hopeful correction), 339–409 (crossing oneself, sibling counsel, acknowledgment, and movement to Christ), 461–497 (three “worried” chapters), 699–765 (restoration, harvest, justice, and mercy), and 930–1000 (productive trouble and “full sway”). Devotional interpretation. The guide does not adopt every speculation about Corianton’s motives as fact. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  4. John Hilton III, “Textual Similarities in the Words of Abinadi and Alma’s Counsel to Corianton,” BYU Studies Quarterly 51, no. 2 (2012), https://byustudies.byu.edu/article/514; open-access record https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol51/iss2/4/. Literary scholarship. Hilton reports at least thirteen textual relationships between Mosiah 12–17 and Alma 39–42, supported by human and computer-assisted comparison. The relationship is persuasive evidence of textual influence in his analysis, not an official canonized statement about Alma’s compositional process. ↩ ↩2

  5. Terry B. Ball, “Alma 39: A Model for Teaching Morality,” Religious Educator 2, no. 2 (2001): 25–36, https://rsc.byu.edu/vol-2-no-2-2001/alma-39-model-teaching-morality. Religious education scholarship and application. Ball identifies a sequence of learner-specific counsel, moral seriousness, effects on others, correction “for thy good,” accountability, repentance, reliable advisors, and the plan of redemption. The guide uses the sequence without treating all of Ball’s cultural examples as timeless or official. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  6. David Butler and Emily Belle Freeman, “Come Follow Me Alma 39–42 (July 27–Aug 2),” Don’t Miss This, local generated transcript Come Follow Me Alma 39–42 (July 27–Aug 2), original video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B6JYzkKD5V0. This is a prior curriculum-cycle transcript whose chapter-specific content remains relevant; its printed dates differ from the 2024 week. See lines 22–77 (one-on-one setting and solution-centered conversation), 120–189 (repentance, counsel, acknowledgment, diligent inquiry, and honest uncertainty), 192–235 (furniture restoration and desires), and 236–339 (justice, law, Eden, and the plan’s names). Devotional teaching application. The furniture image is theirs; the guide supplies explicit limits to the metaphor. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  7. Ryan H. Sharp, “Alma, Ambiguity, and the Development of Doctrinal Understanding,” in Give Ear to My Words: Text and Context of Alma 36–42, ed. Kerry M. Hull, Nicholas J. Frederick, and Hank R. Smith (Religious Studies Center, Brigham Young University; Deseret Book, 2019), 51–72, https://rsc.byu.edu/give-ear-my-words/alma-ambiguity-development-doctrinal-understanding. Historical and textual scholarship. Sharp emphasizes Alma’s diligent inquiry, hierarchy of central and secondary facts, explicit opinion language, and the danger of forcing Alma 40 into a complete diagram built from later revelation. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  8. Daniel B. Sharp, “Justice, Mercy and the Atonement in the Teachings of Alma to Corianton,” in Give Ear to My Words (2019), 73–88, https://rsc.byu.edu/give-ear-my-words/justice-mercy-atonement-teachings-alma-corianton. Textual and theological scholarship. Sharp analyzes how Alma uses Nephite knowledge of the Fall, redemption, law, justice, and mercy to answer Corianton’s concern in Alma 42; the scriptural passage remains the doctrinal primary source. ↩ ↩2

  9. BYU Studies, “The Great Plan of Happiness — Alma 39–42,” Come, Follow Me: Book of Mormon, lesson 32, https://byustudies.byu.edu/come-follow-me/book-of-mormon/32; retained as BYU Studies Come, Follow Me — The Great Plan of Happiness — Alma 39–42. Curated scholarly index, not official Church curriculum. The retained note records every lesson-specific item by chapter and its distinctive contribution. ↩

Graph View

Backlinks